Milo Connelly already had a tendency to overthink before the world started collapsing around him, but ever since Marcos reappeared in his life, it appears as though God Himself has intervened to keep him as on edge as possible. Perpetually a goody-two-shoes and, to most people in his life, deeply religious, Milo is yet again faced with his inescapable love for another boy. Just when he thinks he might be able to manage it, however, a sinkhole opens (literally) beneath his feet. The only person can trust not to despise him for his crush on Marcos is Van, his best friend, because now, in addition to fearing the rejection of his parents, the people at his church, and most of his peers, God Himself has also decided to punish Milo for his sins. That Earth itself seems to be crashing down on top of him is certainly not helping matters. Will Milo choose to stay in line and prevent disaster, or will he be honest about how he feels?